to narrow?!?
If they like to stick in the mud maybe, if they wheel Johnson Valley then they may be saying it cause the guys on 44s like to drive over it, but it is more fun on 35s.
I would say on some of the trails i run at paragon my Taco (05 Quad Cab LB TRD Sport) would barley fit
XJ (Cherokees) have trouble some times.
I love to see the guys that show up with Broncos and blazers on 39s+ and have to stick to the blues and greens cause they don't fit on the fun stuff
they might as well be curb hopping at the local mall.
i wheel a TJ (wrangler) on 35 MTRs, Atlas II 3.8, 4.56s ARBs f/r, 1/4" skids everywhere, custom highsteer, Superiors in the rear and Warns in the front and I stick in the rocks mostly - mud doesn;t do it for me.
There is a reason the guys that run local meets use Zukes most of the time. Cheep, easy and fit everywhere
Go wheeling with some folks, figure out what excites you and build a rig that will work best in that environment
I would think out in cali you guys do a lot of desert and rock with steep hills and klimbs, a fule injected taco would be perfect withthe longer wb and the strong axles
Also, I am of the belief you lift a jeep as little as possible to fit the tires that will give you the clearance required at your diffs.
And yes - 35s can get you over just about anything this side of comp trails.