Someone helped themselves to my driver's side fog light blank cover last night.

It's a 2008 Corolla LE. It's just a piece of black plastic, and it looks like it pops right out of the bumper with no tools. Easy pickin's.
My question is: Does anyone out there who has converted to real fog lights have their old covers laying around? I'm going to check w/the dealer tomorrow, I'm sure they're way overpriced. I'd be happy to buy for a reasonable price and pay shipping to someone on this forum rather than a dealer.
Thanks,
John