Quote:
Originally Posted by extreme one
In over 40 years of car ownership never fooled with the fuel systems.
|
That's the problem right there. You have no experience messing with the fuel system and therefore you are reluctant to mess with it.
I should add that this isn't really messing with the fuel system... this is messing with the air intake system.
Also 40 years ago carbon build up wasn't a big deal. Parts were bigger and had looser tolerances so a little bit of carbon wasn't going to mess things up. These days parts are built barely "big enough" and out of lighter weight materials, and tolerances are much tighter in an effort to reduce weight and friction while increasing economy and durability.
Simply put carbon build up can cause a lot more problem today than it did in the past. Throttle valves can get stuck in it and as a result the computer will "turn off" the gas pedal. Carbon can coat the valves and make them hang open and as a result the computer will go into "failsafe" or "open loop" mode and cause you to fail emissions tests. Also carbon can contaminate the inside of the intake and reduce the efficiency of the fuel/air mixture by screwing up the turbulence of the airflow.
It's a whole new ballgame with cars, especially since they came out with the electronic throttle (AKA Drive-By-Wire) and it is important to keep these things clean.
Does it need to be done all the time? Probably not. I think doing it as 30k maintenance is good enough for most cases.. maybe even still overkill for some but if it's done right it won't hurt anything.
Now for Seafoam.. I won't say that for sure I agree with the complete treatment being necessary. Adding it to the fuel tank is similar to adding fuel injector cleaner and works great as maintenance (although similar additives are already added to fuel plus the ethanol which helps too). Doing the vacuum hose treatment can help clean out the intake and valves. Also manual cleaning of the throttle body can help a lot as well.
I've fixed hundreds of cars with various driveability problems by performing similar cleaning methods - and I'm sure I've prevented many hundreds more by doing this type of service as maintenance.
I disagree with the need to add it to the engine oil. It might work great as an 'engine flush' but as long as good quality oil is used and changed regularly I don't see the need to do this... but definitely if you do choose to do this change the oil shortly after.