After a lot of research I finally ordered a set of upgraded front brakes for my SR5.
For those of you who don't know, the '90-91 GT-S (and prizm GSi) had bigger front brakes than the rest of the corollas.
The discs are 258mm instead of 238mm and 22mm thick instead of 17mm
calipers have different brackets to fit over the bigger discs and I've heard the calipers themselves may or may not be different to accept the wider rotor (I got semi-loaded calipers + brackets just to be safe.
the pads are the same, so you can keep your old ones.
advance auto is having a Cyber Monday sale, so I got the whole package for $95 shipped (+ core charge) with a $50 coupon for my next purchase which is pretty darn good if you ask me
Here are the part numbers, be careful, every place I've checked tries really hard to sell you standard corolla parts, even if you put in '91 GTS:
rotors: 2x YH141669
calipers: SLC8064 and SLC8065
I'll post pictures for comparison when I get them.