go to club4ag and i believe there is a sticky thread in one of the forums about the different general characteristics of the different brands of shocks
"better" depends on what you are looking for
__________________ mr sinister
1987 ae86 - black hatch
--- GTP Light Tune SPL Super Lace Edition
2001 VW GTI 1.8T
--- "Racing" pedals. my website
Last time I checked club4ag they were comparing different japanese shocks, not to say their bad, but sometimes european craftsmanship just surpasses japanese handicraftness
Somehow I find it hard to believe that the world's supply of millions of struts are being churned out by European 'craftsmen' and Japanese 'handicrafters'. Modern production is done by automated machine assembly lines and those pretty welds on your Japanese or European struts are done by robots, not a human's hands.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flashmn
Last time I checked club4ag they were comparing different japanese shocks, not to say their bad, but sometimes european craftsmanship just surpasses japanese handicraftness
its not quality, its how you want to configure your suspension.
for all the big names (be it european, american or japanese) you can pretty much rest assure that all are well built.
however, different strut cartridges display different characteristics.
as posted on club4ag, konis are generally good for grip while really bad for drift. tokico illuminas are a decent entry level drift shock while the hts works wonders for drifting however would not be your chocec for grip. the trd blue adj. are good for drift while the greens, yellows and baby blues are a solid multi use shock.
all different damper and rebound rates, but all good in quality.
and don't think that european shocks aren't used on the ae86, cuz hardcore ae86 tuners in japan utelize Ohlins, Bilsteins and Sachs shocks. if i had the money, i'd definitely go for the Ohlins coil overs...so sweet.
Heh, dont get me wrong here, that handicraftness and craftsmanship wasnt meant to be taken literally. I know that theyare done with robots, but they do have hand built phases too. My bilsteins were infact assembled by hand (from robot made parts ofcourse) and I got some special valving on them. However, I dont think theres that much difference doing drifts with different shocks, maybe at pro level yeah, where each mm is carefully selected. I've drifted cars with practically blown shocks (scary yes), and ones with bilsteins or konis and I gotta say, they both go through the drift as they should, if you know how to control the car.
On another note, I dont think you should choose shocks and springs for a street driven car on basis how they act on a track and how they act doing drifts. Its not like you're gonna do those feats all the time on the street when driving to the mall and back. If you do, heck you shouldnt have a car. When I got my shocks and springs, I was searching different options, with several goals in my mind, well, thing is I had to give away some of those goals to keep my car driveable. I didnt get coil-overs because they generally are harsher, I didnt slam my car. I'd really hate to tell a girl I'm giving a ride "oh sorry I cant go that way, because my car wont go over the speedbumps" ;P
Heh, dont get me wrong here, that handicraftness and craftsmanship wasnt meant to be taken literally. I know that theyare done with robots, but they do have hand built phases too. My bilsteins were infact assembled by hand (from robot made parts ofcourse) and I got some special valving on them. However, I dont think theres that much difference doing drifts with different shocks, maybe at pro level yeah, where each mm is carefully selected. I've drifted cars with practically blown shocks (scary yes), and ones with bilsteins or konis and I gotta say, they both go through the drift as they should, if you know how to control the car.
On another note, I dont think you should choose shocks and springs for a street driven car on basis how they act on a track and how they act doing drifts. Its not like you're gonna do those feats all the time on the street when driving to the mall and back. If you do, heck you shouldnt have a car. When I got my shocks and springs, I was searching different options, with several goals in my mind, well, thing is I had to give away some of those goals to keep my car driveable. I didnt get coil-overs because they generally are harsher, I didnt slam my car. I'd really hate to tell a girl I'm giving a ride "oh sorry I cant go that way, because my car wont go over the speedbumps" ;P
we're not bulshitting you. Moto P has posted a whole section on club4ag explaining the different damper rates on different different shocks and how that affects drifting, gripping or daily driving.
and yes, your suspension setup will adversely affect the ease which you can drift at or grip the course. Longer rebound and damper rates are generally better for gripping and not so good for getting nice long drifts. where as short rebound and damper rates will allow for a very stiff ride and very little travel allowing the ae86's (in our case) tail end to step out easier and maintain a smooth conistent slide.
Sure, driving ability has everything to do with how well you drift or how well you take corners, but having the proper setup will help you steer (no pun intended) yourself in the right direction. work with your car, don't work against it.
by the way my ride is a silver AE92 GTS
i'm lookin at suspension that'll handle street racing well, drop the car about 1-2 inchs, still allowing me 2 go over speed bumps and something thats not to stiff it hurts. For struts i'm seriously concidering Koni's - i think they're the fully adjustable one i'm looking at.
that's another thing, are adjustable's worth spending the extra coin on or mainly just a selling pitch?
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.
ToyotaNation.com is an independent Toyota/Lexus enthusiast website. ToyotaNation.com is not sponsored by or in any way affiliated with Toyota Motor Sales, USA, Inc. The Toyota, Lexus and Scion names and logos are trademarks owned by Toyota Motor Sales, USA, Inc.