The Matrix feels a bit bigger than a compact car. You're also seated higher up. I'd hate to say it but almost minivan like.
I've only driven the XRS w/17" wheels and it handles extremely well for its height.
Basically, I don't think anyone can tell what your brother to get. He's gonna have to decide cuz it's all a matter of personal taste and how comfortable he feels in a certain car.
I think people who aren't "in to" cars will generally choose a car they're most comfortable with and not worry about how much hp or torque a car has.
We can all go on and on about how the Matrix has this or a car has that but it all boils down to what he wants.
Take him out on some test drives!
_________________
Coming soon: Matrix XRS
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: mistamatrix on 2002-04-29 15:51 ]</font>