They'll fit with no problems, but your speedometer will be slightly off. The prices of the two sizes are similar. I can't really recommend a tire type without know what you're looking for meaning all weather, summer only, winter only, etc.
I had the Falken 912's they only lasted me 15k . They still had some thread left, but they just got way too noisy. I have some Michellin mxv4 now, they have a great ride feels like a luxury car now. Look on Tirerack.com you can compare tires, and read reviews.