I just got an 07 Tacoma yesterday and want to sell the rims, the 16" SR5 rims. They are mint. What is a reasonable price to ask? I know they are not cheap from Toyota but not sure the going rate on a private sale.
I just put my 2010 17 inch Tacoma Sport rims up on Craigs List for $250 (they are $505 brand new from the dealership). I sold them in under 20 hours. Thinking back on it I should have asked for closer to the $300 mark. I think they had about 5600 miles on them with a few minor nicks and dings, basically normal road wear to and from work. Good luck, hope this helps!
I sold mine quick also on eHay and made $265 for my 16" OE rims. I think I could have gotten more also, but these came off my 05. You might try $300 or $325? I think if the economy was better we could have gotten about $400 easy.