Toyota Nation Forum banner

1 - 20 of 21 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Last month when I drove home, my Highlander lost all coolant on highway. I immediately exit from highway and engine stop; I manager stop on a local road. I wait until engine cold and fill water. Engine cannot start.

I called a towing and repair shop and tow car to their shop for repair. I called the repair shop next day, the manager told me they will check problem and call me back. After few days, the manager called. He told me engine need replaced and cost $3000 for parts and labor. My 2003 Highlander only has 70K and engine should be in good condition. I ask the manager what engine compression is. He said all are zero. My highlander is V6, it is not possible cylinders on both banks have no compression. Also, after I find coolant leak and stop car in new minutes.

I ask repair shop tow to my garage and start diagnosis myself. I find that many cylinders have water in it, and I think it is header gasket issue. I take off both cylinder header and found cylinder header need re-surface and many valves need re-seat.

I ordered re-build cylinder header from a Texas company. After putting new cylinder header back, engine still cannot start. Out of six ignition coils, three don’t work. After replacing all ignition coils, engine run as before. But check engine light is on, and scanner said I need replace Oxygen sensor.

After replace Oxygen sensor check engine light still on, report Knock sensor has problem. I ordered Knock sensors and Camshaft position sensors and prepare to replace next weekend.

On a Friday when drove home, highlander stop on highway again. This time is due to timing belt broken. I should replace timing belt when I replace cylinder heads.

Then, I replaced timing belt, Knock sensors and Camshaft position sensors. Engine running OK, but check engine light still on. Also, engine is rough on idle. Scanner said multiple cylinders misfire. After I clear code, scan again, it said cylinder 1,3,5 misfire.

I check web, many people suggested that I is caused by vacuum leaks. I try many ways to fix vacuum leaks. Check engine is always on, scanner said multiple cylinder misfire or cylinder 1,3,5 misfire.

I really cannot find any vacuum leaks by inspect intake manifold and hoses. Use start fluid to find leaks is a little dangerous.

In this article (https://www.autocodes.com/p0300_2001_toyota_highlander.html), multiple cylinders misfire may cause by:
Faulty spark plug (s), all spark plugs are new.
Faulty ignition coil (s), not possible, all coils are new, engine running fine before timing belt broken.
Fuel injectors problems, rule out because engine running fine before timing belt broken.
Intake air leak, very likely.
Insufficient cylinders compression, not possible, all cylinder’s compression are normal after replace cylinder headers, (160-190psi on cold engine).
Mass air flow sensor: Sensor is quite clean. I use alcohol washed; it didn't help.

Current condition is very like what this article:

Engine running fine on high RPM, rough on idle. I ordered intake manifold gasket set and will replace them after I back from vocation. I will try start fluid if engine still has problem.

What else should try? What is your suggestion?

Thanks in advance!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
578 Posts
I would check compression on those cylinders in case the valves were damaged from the timing belt breaking
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
Like MGeorge said, start with the mechanical or you may chase this without success.
Do the compression and leak-down tests.
Be sure to disable the ignition and fuel. Compression tests without disabling can damage the coils and flood the catalytic converters.
Are you certain the cams are timed correctly? Being a tooth off on Bank 1 could cause misfire in those cylinders
If you are not using Toyota or Denso cools and sensors, the new ones may have failed.
Does your scanner read real-time data? If so, what are your fuel trims at idle and while at highway speeds?
Use a stethoscope to listen around the intake manifold and vacuum hoses.
You can get a smoke tester at Amazon to check for vacuum leaks. Look on YouTube for the procedure.
Misfire with good fuel trims would point to ignition, mechanical, or timing.
What was the original cause of the coolant loss? The 1MZ does not usually blow head gaskets without overheating.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
Like MGeorge said, start with the mechanical or you may chase this without success.
Do the compression and leak-down tests.
Be sure to disable the ignition and fuel. Compression tests without disabling can damage the coils and flood the catalytic converters.
Are you certain the cams are timed correctly? Being a tooth off on Bank 1 could cause misfire in those cylinders
If you are not using Toyota or Denso cools and sensors, the new ones may have failed.
Does your scanner read real-time data? If so, what are your fuel trims at idle and while at highway speeds?
Use a stethoscope to listen around the intake manifold and vacuum hoses.
You can get a smoke tester at Amazon to check for vacuum leaks. Look on YouTube for the procedure.
Misfire with good fuel trims would point to ignition, mechanical, or timing.
What was the original cause of the coolant loss? The 1MZ does not usually blow head gaskets without overheating.
Thank you.
To disable fuel, I un-plug fuel pump fuse.
To disable ignition, I remove all coils, is that correct? Should I remove fuse as well?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
If you just unplug the fuel pump there will still be pressure in the fuel rail to inject fuel. The Haynes manual instructions are to remove the fuel cap and unplug the fuel pump and run the engine until it stalls. I don’t know the details of the 2003 wiring to know if you can unplug a fuel pump fuse and still run the engine. On the 2005 there are two EFI fuses. For the ignition system, I unplug and remove the coils. If you don’t have the Haynes manual yet, I think it is a good investment.
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
8,058 Posts
Well, if you had catastrophic coolant loss INTO the engine, you hydrolocked it. Or overheated. or both. As engines are now aluminum, you might as well cracked engine block or done damage to connecting rods/bearings. Who knows. Hydrolocked engines are pretty much toast.
that's, of course, if you had coolant in cylinders because of head gasket failure, not just because you removed engine heads and coolant leaked into them.Your call, you did the job.
Also, out of curiosity. Shop offered you rebuilt engine (no new engines for that money) for $3000. How much did it cost YOU to do all the work? New heads, sensors, coils, etc?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
I am back from vocation and start working on my Highlander.
I have two cars; highlander is just for move large item and go out with my wife on weekend.
Highlander has only 70K and I just don’t want junk this engine.

I made smoke tester; no clear vacuum leaks found.
I re-check timing is correct for bank 1. No error found.
I open cylinder header cover, and make sure timing is correct on marks on camshaft gears (there are one dot and two dots marks on gears).

I than did compress test.
For Bank 2 (front), all cylinders are ~160 psi.
For Bank 1 (close to driver), all cylinders are ~60 psi.
I did compression test with my compressor:
  • Remove camshaft and make sure all valves are seated.
  • All six cylinders reaches 120 psi, when I stop compressor, pressure drop slowly in the same way.
I use a Wi-Fi endoscope to inspect inside cylinders, no clear damages found. All valve looks OK.
I removed shim one by one, all valve is installed correctly, no sign locker pops up.

After all this, my compulsion is:
It is timing caused low compression on bank one.
The only possibility is bank 1 VVT timing is wrong. I just cannot find any error on timing mark alignment.

I tested VVT solenoid, both are working. I ordered two new solenoids, but I don’t think it will help.
The other possibility is bank one intake camshaft gear damaged. I googled for hours, cannot find any article on how to diagnosis that.

I order a scanner with read real-time data, will do test when I put everything back.

Any suggestions are greatly appreciated.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
You did a good job of troubleshooting. If all Bank 1 cylinders are 60 during a compression test but 120 during a leak-down yes with a compressor then it sounds like camshaft timing is off by a couple of teeth
You need to check timing in two places on bank1. 1) Camshaft to crankshaft timing at the timing belt. 2) intake and exhaust camshaft gear timing at the back of the head.
It is not clear to me that you checked both. If not then check the timing belt again.
One other way- Move each piston to top dead center (TDC) on the compression stroke and check the angle of the cam lobes for the cylinder. The angles for the intake and exhaust lobes should be the same for all cylinders. I think you will find that Bank 1 doesn’t match Bank 2.
I suppose it is possible that the cam phaser is stuck but I think it would be in the phaser mechanism and not in the solenoid to show up in a compression test.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
You did a good job of troubleshooting. If all Bank 1 cylinders are 60 during a compression test but 120 during a leak-down yes with a compressor then it sounds like camshaft timing is off by a couple of teeth
You need to check timing in two places on bank1. 1) Camshaft to crankshaft timing at the timing belt. 2) intake and exhaust camshaft gear timing at the back of the head.
It is not clear to me that you checked both. If not then check the timing belt again.
One other way- Move each piston to top dead center (TDC) on the compression stroke and check the angle of the cam lobes for the cylinder. The angles for the intake and exhaust lobes should be the same for all cylinders. I think you will find that Bank 1 doesn’t match Bank 2.
I suppose it is possible that the cam phaser is stuck but I think it would be in the phaser mechanism and not in the solenoid to show up in a compression test.
A new intake gear cost only $100 on Ebay, may be I should order one.
I am not sure how easy to replace it.

Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
Well, I think I would do more diagnostics.

The Haynes manual has a lot of good information on the cams and phasers. If you don’t have it, consider getting it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
I do have Haynes manual.
Following Haynes manual:
  • First, I make sure sprocket/actuator cannot rotate.
  • I use compressor, released locker and actuator rotate freely by hand.
  • When I rotate all the way to right, actuator lock again.
  • Compare new lock position to previous position, at least more than one tooth different.
I use gasoline cleaned vvt gear and fill some clean oil.

Tomorrow I will test compression again. If compression is good, I will make engine run again. I think I don’t need replace sprocket/actuator.

I find an article on web, it said that if VVT gear in on activated phase and engine quickly stop, sprocket/actuator may get stuck. That is what happened when timing belt broken.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
Nice work. Just be careful with using gasoline as a solvent. I use Chemtool or other carburetor cleaners
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
I finally fixed my Highlander.

After I clean VVT gear and reinstall everything, check engine light still on, but less frequent. After I clean code, I can drive long distance, bur check engine light still on and code scan report same cylinder 1,3,5 misfire and random misfire.

My rebuilt cylinder head from Cylinder Head International has one-year unlimited warranty. When they delivery, there is a note that said that call them for any problem before take head off. I called them; customer support ask me send bank one head back to them. This is not an easy job, but I think it is the best choice. Timing belt broken on highway may cause serious damaged on head, valve bent and VVT gear damaged.

After I replace bank one-cylinder head, check engine light never come back. Car is in very good condition.

Leaking coolant is very hard to damage whole engine. Yes, highlander cylinder block is made of aluminum, but damage on cylinder block and pistons are not noticeable. However, machine shop doesn’t want to take chance. Replace an engine is much safe for them. Timing belt broken can cause more serious damage on Cylinder Head, for Highlander's VVTi engine, cylinder Head is very complicated.

If I agreed to replace engine, my less than 78K engine will be replace with a 200K engine and $4000 charges. Total cost for replace a rebuild Cylinder Head is less than $1200 and my time. I will drive this car to 200K and not afraid of fixing anything (learn from mistakes, I made many mistakes, for example timing belt broke is cause my mistake).

I would like thanks everyone’s help, specially C R. My experience may be helpful for any highlander owner.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
102 Posts
What was your mistake for the timing belt breaking?

Also buy denso coils and dont cheap out on coils. The cheap ones dont work 50% of the time and go bad quickly

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
See the other thread:

Camshaft Sprocket Flanges In or Out (for Timing Belt Change)

The two pulleys go on differently. Rear has the flange point away from the engine and the front has the flange towards the engine.

I didn't read repair manual carefully, belt broke after one week.
If both flange point away from the engine, timing belt will touch engine body.
This mistake cause me a timing belt and few days time.

I bought Toyota OEM coils from EBay. Coils are made by Denso, but different parts number.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
Be careful of buying parts on EBay if you are planning to keep the car. There are a lot of counterfeit parts out there these days and Amazon and EBay are good ways to distribute them.
Often RockAuto has good prices on Denso and McGeorge Toyota parts online has very good prices for OEM.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
702 Posts
I should also point out that I have never heard of parts actually sold by Amazon be counterfeit.
I would be more concerned about parts sold on Amazon by a third party that I do not recognize
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter #20
After struggle for weeks and finally have happy ending. My Highlander is in great running condition. Pushing gas pedal halfway down, car reaches 70 mph in few seconds. Maybe the last mistake is that I didn’t buy sensors and ignition coils from reputable source. After fixed cylinder headers, engine fail to start. Therefore, I replaced all coils and sensors. Real problem is ignition coils and Knock sensors (its plastic melt when engine overheat). I checked RockAuto web site, Denso coil is $53. Other sensors are cheap as well (about $40 each). I have two options:
  1. Keep current condition, hopefully when a coil or sensor break, check engine light will on, I can drive home and replace it. Certain parts break can cause serious problem and you need tow car home, like timing belt broke. I don’t want that happen again.
  2. Replace them right now. I keep all old parts I removed from car, I have three good coils, and two VVT solenoids are good. Maybe I can use them.
Thank you for your suggestions.
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
Top