Toyota Nation Forum banner
1 - 15 of 15 Posts

· Registered
2017 Camry SE
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I am new and have recently had a brake service experience with my '17 Camry SE that has led me to join this site and seek insight.

For a while I experienced an intermittent issue of vibration from the front right side of the car, especially on hotter days. That tire would have several PSI more than all the others and my fuel economy was down. I figured I had a wheel balancing or alignment issue, so I took it to Tires Plus who told me it was a sticking brake caliper (at 69k miles!). Thankfully my pads and rotors weren't worn down from it so they just replaced the caliper, though now I am wishing I had just done it myself. I wanted it to just be done though so I willingly paid more than I knew I had to.

The other thing is that they insisted that they needed to change all the brake fluid in case that heat damaged it. Now whenever I've brought a Toyota to a dealership or anywhere everyone wants to change brake fluid and I never let them. This time I felt like I had no choice, and I had a feeling that when I got the car back, the braking was just not going to be the same, like my old '96 Buick Century or my sister's '03 Corolla: not poor, but not like a newer car, you know what I mean.

I had to have my mother pick up the car for me because I work nights. Evidently the shop was still wrapping up the work after their closing time. I got in the car to go to work the next day and sure enough it was like pressing the brake on my antique. Twice the amount of pedal was needed; no more of that immediate grip with a feather touch, almost too touchy (which I read in another thread was considered an issue on these?).

Disheartened and angered I immediately got it into a dealership to have them properly bleed the whole brake system, including the ABS module and master cylinder. When I got it back from them they told me that brake performance was restored and the bleed was successful. My evaluation is that they brought it from 75% to 85-90% of what it was. With the same brake application used from muscle memory I still barrel forward, only slowing down very gradually, definitely inadequately so I need to press harder.

What I wonder is am I chasing a fantasy and being too fussy? It doesn't brake poorly or dangerously; I would say it brakes okay as far as cars go, but before it braked exceptionally well. I don't know what else can be done if they truly bled all the air out, and the dealership's estimation was that this is normal performance. Is it impossible to get that back once the system is opened up like that? Is that touchy performance actually a flaw and abnormal and this is the true normal? Any insight or experience is greatly appreciated.
 

· Registered
2012 Camry XLE V6
Joined
·
215 Posts
If the caliper truly was sticking, you may have gotten used to a more immediate response since the piston would have been pressing much closer against the pads.

You mentioned the caliper was replaced by tires plus, did they use a new OEM or a remanufactured? This could definitely be a potential issue.

As for bleeding, it would be fairly simple to perform a basic bleed on all 4 calipers just for peace of mind. Don't have to worry about getting air in the abs module so long as you don't run the reservoir dry.

If all the air is evacuated, you can try things like more aggressive brake pads and steel braided brake lines which will definitely enhance the experience. I believe the much larger calipers and rotors from the Highlander bolt up directly and provide a fairly substantial upgrade.
 

· Registered
2017 Camry SE
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
If the caliper truly was sticking, you may have gotten used to a more immediate response since the piston would have been pressing much closer against the pads.

You mentioned the caliper was replaced by tires plus, did they use a new OEM or a remanufactured? This could definitely be a potential issue.

As for bleeding, it would be fairly simple to perform a basic bleed on all 4 calipers just for peace of mind. Don't have to worry about getting air in the abs module so long as you don't run the reservoir dry.

If all the air is evacuated, you can try things like more aggressive brake pads and steel braided brake lines which will definitely enhance the experience. I believe the much larger calipers and rotors from the Highlander bolt up directly and provide a fairly substantial upgrade.
It was a Cardone reman. Looked like a decent part to me from what I researched. You make an interesting point. Now I need to drive another Camry and compare lol.

So as far as bleeding, the night I drove it I bled all 4 myself the traditional way and was still unsatisfied. My friend at work suggested they didn't bleed the ABS, since they did change the whole amount of fluid out, but I do not know what process by which they did so.
 

· Registered
2012 Camry XLE V6
Joined
·
215 Posts
It was a Cardone reman. Looked like a decent part to me from what I researched. You make an interesting point. Now I need to drive another Camry and compare lol.

So as far as bleeding, the night I drove it I bled all 4 myself the traditional way and was still unsatisfied. My friend at work suggested they didn't bleed the ABS, since they did change the whole amount of fluid out, but I do not know what process by which they did so.
I have not had great experiences with cardone in the past, though I understand sometimes it's the only option. Usually try to get brake remans thru Centric when I can.
 

· Registered
2012 Camry SE, 4 cyl
Joined
·
790 Posts
Changing the fluid was correct. The fluid absorbs moisture. Moisture causes parts like the calipers piston to freeze up (internal rust).

I try to do this every 3 or 4 years.

Pads may also be positioned differently then before when you had the sticking caliper. May take a while for the pads to wear in again to provide lower pedal force.
 

· Registered
2017 Camry SE
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I have not had great experiences with cardone in the past, though I understand sometimes it's the only option. Usually try to get brake remans thru Centric when I can.
What's there to look out for with these parts then?

I think you may be on to something about getting used to a feel that truly isn't the normal.

So do you other Camry owners have to push a little bit to get braking or is there an immediate grab with a slight touch? Can you describe it? I really wish I could drive another car to see. I really don't wanna piss off the shop and waste their time if it's really normal xD.
 

· Super Moderator
2021 HiHy Platinum AWD
Joined
·
2,477 Posts
In order to change a caliper, you have to remove the brake line from the caliper, then hopefully you didn't lose too much brake fluid during the process, and it's going to take some brake fluid to bleed out the new caliper, so, might as well flush the fluid fluid.

I'm surprised the dealership didn't try to sell you new brake pads to see if it fixed the problem with brake feel, since the aftermarket pads could be the culprit for the change in brake feel.

You can also give it some time to naturally bed in and feel may improve also.

When I had Centric Posi-Quiet Ceramic pads installed on my Tiguan, it was high effort with low brake power. I survived a little longer and one late night, when the roads are empty, I went out and bedded the pads, with about ten 65-5 mph full brake stops to heat up the pads and transfer a pad layer to the rotors, and then drive on cruise control for another half hour before heading home. Later that morning, after the brakes have completely cooled down, brake feel and performance was instantly improved.
 

· Registered
'17 Camry XSE; '17 Rav4 XLE
Joined
·
167 Posts
I survived a little longer and one late night, when the roads are empty, I went out and bedded the pads, with about ten 65-5 mph full brake stops to heat up the pads and transfer a pad layer to the rotors, and then drive on cruise control for another half hour before heading home. Later that morning, after the brakes have completely cooled down, brake feel and performance was instantly improved.
I've done many brake jobs and figured I didn't need to read the instructions - if provided - but one time I did and this was their recommendation. Now I do it after every brake job. I also found that purchasing quality parts helps vs the cheapest the store has to offer.
 

· Super Moderator
2021 HiHy Platinum AWD
Joined
·
2,477 Posts
I've done many brake jobs and figured I didn't need to read the instructions - if provided - but one time I did and this was their recommendation. Now I do it after every brake job. I also found that purchasing quality parts helps vs the cheapest the store has to offer.
For the posi-quiet ceramic, I reached out to Centric and they said bedding by repeated stops was not necessary prior to install.

EBC redstuff on a Passat before the Tiguan, they recommended bedding from repeated stops, but never had the chance and never had issues

Akebono Euro Ceramic, Akebono instructions said gently braking for the first 100 or so miles. On the Passat, I hit a deer the next workday because I couldn’t stop in time. The Tiguan, no issues breaking in the pads
 

· Registered
Joined
·
65 Posts
I am new and have recently had a brake service experience with my '17 Camry SE that has led me to join this site and seek insight.

For a while I experienced an intermittent issue of vibration from the front right side of the car, especially on hotter days. That tire would have several PSI more than all the others and my fuel economy was down. I figured I had a wheel balancing or alignment issue, so I took it to Tires Plus who told me it was a sticking brake caliper (at 69k miles!). Thankfully my pads and rotors weren't worn down from it so they just replaced the caliper, though now I am wishing I had just done it myself. I wanted it to just be done though so I willingly paid more than I knew I had to.

The other thing is that they insisted that they needed to change all the brake fluid in case that heat damaged it. Now whenever I've brought a Toyota to a dealership or anywhere everyone wants to change brake fluid and I never let them. This time I felt like I had no choice, and I had a feeling that when I got the car back, the braking was just not going to be the same, like my old '96 Buick Century or my sister's '03 Corolla: not poor, but not like a newer car, you know what I mean.

I had to have my mother pick up the car for me because I work nights. Evidently the shop was still wrapping up the work after their closing time. I got in the car to go to work the next day and sure enough it was like pressing the brake on my antique. Twice the amount of pedal was needed; no more of that immediate grip with a feather touch, almost too touchy (which I read in another thread was considered an issue on these?).

Disheartened and angered I immediately got it into a dealership to have them properly bleed the whole brake system, including the ABS module and master cylinder. When I got it back from them they told me that brake performance was restored and the bleed was successful. My evaluation is that they brought it from 75% to 85-90% of what it was. With the same brake application used from muscle memory I still barrel forward, only slowing down very gradually, definitely inadequately so I need to press harder.

What I wonder is am I chasing a fantasy and being too fussy? It doesn't brake poorly or dangerously; I would say it brakes okay as far as cars go, but before it braked exceptionally well. I don't know what else can be done if they truly bled all the air out, and the dealership's estimation was that this is normal performance. Is it impossible to get that back once the system is opened up like that? Is that touchy performance actually a flaw and abnormal and this is the true normal? Any insight or experience is greatly appreciated.
I had trouble with tire balancing at Tires Plus. Just saying
 

· Registered
2017 Camry SE
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
I had trouble with tire balancing at Tires Plus. Just saying
Lol

Well maybe the first suggestion here was on to something. Both places say it's all good. Maybe I was used to something more sensitive than normal. I will say this Tires Plus really was nice and wanted to make sure it was all good so they didn't charge me after coming back. I mean I did pay a good amount in all. Thanks all.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top