Toyota Forum banner

2009 vs 2010 Camry (4 cylinder)

18K views 11 replies 8 participants last post by  Luke_ak45  
#1 ·
I have been looking at used 2009 and 2010 Camrys. Before I test drove any of them, I thought I would prefer the 2010 model since it has 11 more horsepower, a 6-speed transmission instead of a 5, and has stability control standard. But after driving them both, I am having trouble deciding which one would work better for me. The 2009 that I drove seemed to shift more smoothly than the 2010 model in traffic. Does the 2009 model have a smoother shifting transmission or is it possible that the 2010 model that I test drove just hasn't had the latest TSB done on the transmission? Although I like the extra horsepower and safety features on the 2010 model, I would purchase a 2009 model if it had a smoother shifting transmission. The car will be driven exclusively in town so it is important that I get a car that will drive well in heavy traffic. For those of you that have driven both models, which one do you think should drive better in town?
 
#2 ·
There is a TSB out for the 2010 & 2011 for the transmission. Ask the dealer if it was applied or was the test vehicle you drove manufactured after the TSB date.
 
#3 ·
I believe that the 2010 will drive smoother, with TSB or not, because it has dual variable timing as apposed to the 09's single variable timing

I own an 09 SE and usually drive my dad's '10 LE back and forth hauling stuff that needs the backseat folded down.

Although I feel the downshift between 20-30(his car's under the TSB), my dad's '10 acceleration and upshifting felt very smooth
 
#4 ·
Mine don't.... not smooth at all.... I will get the TSB applied at my next service. And the dealer said the Power Steering whine is normal, I disagree......... Any body else with the I4 and have a PS whine?
 
#5 ·
I own a 2011 base I4 auto and have driven several I4 5sp auto 2007-2009 Camrys ( I work at a shop and do tires & alignments). I think the 5 sp auto is a somewhat smoother trans and less shift busy. After 4000 miles, I have gotten used to the 6sp plus the shifting seems much better as the miles increase. I find the 2.5/6sp noticeably quicker than the 2.4/5sp. I read here about the 2010/2011 trans TSB but mine was made well after the cut off vin.
As for Luna2s' power steering whine question, I do get a whine in my car but I don't think it's from the ps. I believe it's from the trans but another 2011 I test drove sounded similar so I'm not worried by it. It is not as loud a whine noise as most newer Mercedes make!
 
#6 ·
I had a dealer check the whine and by removing the serpentine belt it disappeared. I drove two I4 cars while on travel and the whine was undetectable. It sounds like the PS pump has a cavitation problem in my car. (A restriction problem in the pressure bypass/return line, most noticeable between 2000 to 2800 rpm.)
 
#7 ·
The 2az engine in the 2009 has been known for the head bolt issue at any time after 80k miles. So I'd go with the 2010 to be safe if I were you. My grandfathers 2011 shifts as smooths as butter. Though it's no where's close to my V6
 
#10 ·
Yes, the TSB applies to 2011 6-speed automatics with the 4 cyl. but it's dependent on the vin # and plant the car was built in. A quick search will find the tsb, it's posted here somewhere. My 2011 base Camry 4 cyl 6 sp. auto was very "busy" feeling at first, worst at lower speed/light throttle conditions. it has become much better now at 4,000 miles. Mine was built after the vin cut-off for the TSB.
 
#12 ·
I've changed the power steering fluid twice, last time at 180000km and the whining is almost unoticeable comparing with before. But the whining it was always there since I purchased the car at 137000km. Not sure if is normal or not for this model. I guess less whining is good and loud is time to change the fluid...