I bought a 97 GTI/VR6 new in 1997. I actually sold a brand new at the time 1996 Corvette to buy the GTI. The Vette was a piece of crap. Chevy's customer service stunk. Horrible experience for their top line car! The Vette had so many problems that it had to go back to Bowling Green KY to get the issues sorted out. I never saw it again, filed the Lemon ordeal and almost a year later bought the GTI.
I had the GTI from 97 to 02 and put 196,000 miles on it. Never had one problem with that car! Just regular maintenance. Now, I don't know if the same can be said for the new ones. BUT, out of all the cars I have owned in recent memory, it was the best.
After the GTI, I had 2 Passat TDI's. Owning those cars ruined VW for me. Too much crap to list. Needless to say I will NEVER own a VW again!
After the TDI's, I went to a new Mercedes e320 CDI. At that point in time, the Mercedes was the only car I had owned that was better than the GTI (many cars before, too many to list). Cost of ownership with Diesels is high in regards to maintenance, and then the cost of fuel now. The stellar economy is still not enough to compensate for the costs of VERY expensive oil changes with hard to find filters, frequent and expensive fuel filter changes and expensive fuel. Then god forbid a problem with the engine! Fixing Diesel when things go wrong is $$$.
Then there's the TCH. What a great "all around car"! I have had my share of piddly problems like the water pump, trunk switch rubber, etc... But, over all the car is just tough as nails. We almost have 250,000 miles on ours and I have no intention on selling it anytime soon. Both the batteries are original, it still has the original pads and rotors, etc... It has just been a workhorse for our family! The only real downside to the car is the trunk. Now ours is an older one. I think the newer ones have a little larger trunk. BUT, every time we get in the car, we use the trunk and we are constantly trying to find new and creative ways to cram stuff in there! LOL! Time for a HIHY! Touch'e...