Don't automatically eliminate buying new. As a long time used car buyer (I normally buy used from private parties), back in February I was also looking at 2 to 3 year old Corollas and decided for comparison sake, to send out email messages to several dozen new car dealers, both in state and surrounding states, for their best price on a new 2010 LE. As it turns out, I eneded up buying a new 2010 LE for about the same or less than most of the used ones I was looking at. There are a few dealers that are very hungry for every sale they can get, and the internet makes it easier than ever to find them.