Toyota Forum banner

I received an offer from Carvana.

19K views 89 replies 24 participants last post by  BudmanTom  
#1 ·
I received an email from Carvana so I took the bait and input all the pertinent information, they offered me $22,000 I was pleasantly surprised.

I have a 2020 Camry SE with the 2.5L engine and no real add-ons, I paid $25,500 OTD almost 6 months ago. The offer is $3,500 under what I paid but nearly $2500 in taxes & registration so to use a brand new car for $1000 isn't horrible (obviously I would lose $3500 but they don't benefit from my taxes or registration).

I'm not a big fan of Carvana because they are a bit over priced but for them to offer me $1000 under what I paid is more than fair.
 
#3 ·
I see a ton of ads from Carvana- and their prices seem way too high. One of my friends bought a car from them- and I almost choked when they told me how much they paid. They bought a two year old Chevy Equinox and paid almost as much as they would have if they would have bought new and had decent negotiating skills.

I just did a quick look and found that they have a 2020 1.5t Accord Sport with 2,500 miles listed for $28,590. The MSRP of a BRAND NEW 2021 Accord Sport is $27,430. KBB indicates that the "fair market price of a brand new Accord Sport is $26,600- although dealers in my area would sell it for around $25,000.

Why would anyone buy that car from Carvana for $28,590? That's insane. I bought my 2019 Accord Sport with the upgraded 2.0t engine for less than that- brand new- and it had an MSRP of $33,500.

328996


Same exact thing for a 2020 Camry SE:
Carvana has one listed with 2,500 miles and are charging $25,600 for it. (And it says that someone is buying it) Looking at KBB.com, you can buy a brand new 2021 Camry SE from a Toyota dealership for $24,800. Why would anyone pay $25,600 for a used car when you can buy a brand new version of the same car for $1000 less? That 2020 doesn't even have any real option packages included. The only option that is listed is floor mat/trunk mat option package!
328998

328999



Madness! Are people that much in a hurry to spend their stimulus checks that they won't even take the time to realize that they are paying well above market value?
 
#5 ·
I see a ton of ads from Carvana- and their prices seem way too high. One of my friends bought a car from them- and I almost choked when they told me how much they paid. They bought a two year old Chevy Equinox and paid almost as much as they would have if they would have bought new and had decent negotiating skills.

I just did a quick look and found that they have a 2020 1.5t Accord Sport with 2,500 miles listed for $28,590. The MSRP of a BRAND NEW 2021 Accord Sport is $27,430. KBB indicates that the "fair market price of a brand new Accord Sport is $26,600- although dealers in my area would sell it for around $25,000.

Why would anyone buy that car from Carvana for $28,590? That's insane. I bought my 2019 Accord Sport with the upgraded 2.0t engine for less than that- brand new- and it had an MSRP of $33,500.



Same exact thing for a 2020 Camry SE:
Carvana has one listed with 2,500 miles and are charging $25,600 for it. (And it says that someone is buying it) Looking at KBB.com, you can buy a brand new 2021 Camry SE from a Toyota dealership for $24,800. Why would anyone pay $25,600 for a used car when you can buy a brand new version of the same car for $1000 less? That 2020 doesn't even have any real option packages included. The only option that is listed is floor mat/trunk mat option package!




Madness! Are people that much in a hurry to spend their stimulus checks that they won't even take the time to realize that they are paying well above market value?
Maybe the stimulus checks and low inventory due to covid.... it's crazy!
 
#6 ·
I refuse to shop anywhere like Carvana or CarMax that has a "no haggle" policy and the second half of this thread so far is exactly why. I am the haggle queen and I love a good bargain.
These places are good for selling your car and that's it! (y)
 
#13 ·
I refuse to shop anywhere like Carvana or CarMax that has a "no haggle" policy.
Carmax has sold new Toyotas for since 1998. (But they did sell the two franchises within last six months and waiting for total ownership control) The "no haggle pricing" is no joke on new Toyotas. I got my 2020 SE for almost $5k less on the MSRP. Didn't charge me for hidden fees. When I bought my 2020 back in August; they allowed me to test it alone. Asked how I liked it. Agreed to fill out the application. Received loan offer within 5 minutes. Told them I accepted it. They prepped the vehicle while doing my paperwork. Signed the papers. Transfer my stuff from my old 2012 to 2020. Drove out 3 1/2 hours later. Not once I got pressured into buying it.

This is my fifth vehicle from Carmax (aka Kenosha Toyota).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8thgencamryowner
#15 · (Edited)
Oddly enough, out of sheer curiosity I checked the value of my car on Edmunds website yesterday, and it gave me a CarMax instant offer of $19,100. Then I see this thread and decided to check Carvana too. I didn't like that I had to put in my email address and how much I owe, etc. But the offer was better, $19,800 approx, $700 more and they will come pick it up for free. Not bad for a base 2019 SE with 29k miles and no options. However it is in excellent condition and I'm pretty sure my color has the highest resale value too.

Recent pic from a few days ago to prove the condition lol:
329083
 
#26 ·
My personal sales consultant from Carmax. Sold me four of the five vehicles. She told me one day; before the 2008 recession that she was bringing in over $75k selling new Toyotas & Chevys. Because it was just too easy to sell back then and commission was really good even at Carmax. She was one of three consultants who were allowed to sell Toyota, Chevy, and used which Toyota frowns on at the usual dealership. Typically, a salesperson is only allowed to sell new or just used. Since her location sold the Toyota rights; she got offered management position to stick around.
 
#19 ·
Does Carvana offer financing?
For many, they buy what can be financed and care less about price or interest....just that eternal monthly payment

I was shocked when shopping for a new car....dealers offering 72-84 month financing. If you can't pay it off in 36 months, you are shopping above your means.
Carvana and Carmax, etc. all do offer financing.
 
#24 ·
Timely thread. I, too, sold a vehicle -- a 2019 Honda Ridgeline RLT AWD -- to Carvana. And, as others have written above, I was drawn in initially by the amount I was offered online. Because I had purchased my Ridgeline in Nov. 2019 for nearly $4k less than the MSRP ($33,800) -- which certainly seemed like a super deal at the time -- what I was offered by Carvana, $35,002, worked out to just over $1200 more than I paid for it in 2019. That just seemed too good to pass up. I mean, how often can you by buy, own outright, drive to your heart's content, and then sell a vehicle for $1200 more than you paid for it two years prior? Not often, I dare say; not for just an ordinary, mass-produced truck.

Moreover, what really impressed me, however, was how quickly I received payment for my truck. Carvana's offer and the subsequent sale's agreement stated that, because I opted for electronic payment directly to my bank, that would speed the process, and that I could expect to receive payment within 1-to-2 days. In fact, Carvana picked up my Ridgeline at 1:58 p,m. last Tuesday and I received my direct payment at 3:40 a.m. Wednesday, 11 hours 40 minutes after the sale. Needless to say, I was impressed. Still am.

Oh, and I should add that the "inspection" of my truck by the "appraiser" consisted of her turning the ignition key to the "on" position and verifying the odometer read as I'd stated in my original description of the truck. The woman never drove my truck. Nor did she even started the engine. I'd been with her from the time she arrived, and she never asked to see anything; never opened the hood, the rear storage area (in the bed), nothing. I gave her both keys, she placed them in a lockbox attached to driver's door window and locked the truck. That was it. She signed and handed me the sales agreement, and left. I asked if she wanted to come inside, have a soda, anything? Nope. I went to lunch with my wife, and when we returned home two hours later, the truck was gone. My neighbors came over to tell me they had seen it being loaded on a flatbed by the "smallest woman" they had ever seen.

I'm now considering buying a Toyota, and for some strange reason that I've yet to process, I'm drawn to a 2.0-liter Corolla SE sedan. Go figure. I'd prefer a car with a manual transmission, but they apparently are somewhat hard to find (but are still discounted; an important fact among my car/truck buying habits). I doubt that I'll own it for two years depreciation free, but you never know these days.
 
#25 ·
I recently sold my 2018 RavLE lease to Carmax, my lease was ending in June. Buy out was $15.8k, residual $15.1k. Carmax offered $18.3, Carvana $15k, Shift $17.5k, Vroom $17.3k. Carmax was pain free and gave me a week to decide, I shopped it to a couple of dealers but none would go above $17.5k. Once I went back to Carmax it took 45 min and I had check $2500 and Toyota Finance got their check a week later.
 
#28 ·
I have sold 1 car via Carmax and 2 with Carvana.
Interesting that Carmax requires a visit and thoroughly inspects and drives the car before making an offer.
With Carvana I just answered a few questions, submitted the form and was immediately given an offer.
We made an appointment to pick up the vehicle.
When they arrived, they knocked on my door, we did some very quick paperwork and they handed me a check for the agreed amount.
They then just started the vehicle and loaded onto the truck.
I was quite surprised but very satisfied.
 
#32 ·
Sorry to keep reviving this thread but I keep playing with these sites and today's lucky numbers are:

Vroom - $23,100
Carvana - $23,677
Kelly Blue Book (private party) - $27,000
KBB (trade in) - $23,855

That's with 8600 miles, my initial purchase price was $23k plus $2k in tax and $500 in registration for a total of $25,500.
 
#33 ·
Did you try shift.com as well? They were one of the higher ones too...
 
#37 ·
Sort of, its a seller's market so most cars' values are high right now. Will see how long this lasts, but as long as the chip shortage stays in effect.
 
#38 ·
It works out the same, if you are replacing the vehicle you are selling, they are getting top dollar, if you are just selling a great time. I sold a 2018 leased RAV 4 limited last October with 4,000 miles on it because it was my wifes car and she had just passed away, did not need the car. Had 1.5 years of payments left. Carmax gave me $24,000 for it, and the payoff to the dealer was $24,018 so i broke even. Had i just sold back to Toyota my payoff would have been $26,000 but dealer payoffs from SETF are different from the individual to dealer, if you get a great price from Carvana or Vroom, make sure you are getting the dealer payoff, because could be a big difference.
 
#40 ·
A little update with 8950 miles

Vroom 23,966
Carvana 23,166
KBB 24,258 (trade in)
I did the KBB offer and it said $22,400 (if I remember correctly) but their dealer offered $21,500 another one called yesterday I'm not holding my breath.

No go with Shift and Carmax wants to see it.
 
#50 ·
I just received an email from the Dealership that services my Toyota. The email stated that they want to buy my car and will pay $500 over KBB. This is extremely unusual from my past experience. In the past I used to always take a car that I was ready to sell to a dealership to see what they would offer, just out of curiosity. I always end up selling cars on the private market. In the past dealerships would not even come close to KBB prices, let alone pay over that amount. Dealerships must definitely have big inventory problems.
 
#54 ·
Market prices change so what it was 6 months ago is likely less than what the value would be now.
 
#57 ·
The prices I was quoted 6mo ago were very high, almost what I paid brand new. My car does have extremely low miles though. With the extra $500 on top of the KBB price, it’s about what I paid new. Still not interested in selling but thanks for all the advice. The car I’m referring to is a 2019 Camry XSE.
 
#58 ·
No point selling a car you want to keep or unless you can find another vehicle that you that isn't overpriced right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LLH and EGToy
#60 ·
I've seen dealers list used cars for more than their MSRP new. IDK, but I'd be appalled that anyone would have to pay that amount these days. Exactly why right now isn't a great time to buy a car, used or new unless you really have to or can work a deal where you come out on top (like going from a slightly used car with lots of equity into a new one that still has incentives).
 
#61 ·
Here's a good example of a perennial Toyota owner who bought a 2020 Honda Civic Si last year that now had much equity, he flipped it to get back into a Tacoma on lease.