Toyota Forum banner

5W20 instead of 5W30

30K views 32 replies 18 participants last post by  fenixus  
#1 ·
Hi guys,
I got a can of Q Horsepower Synth. 5W20 instead of 5W30 for my 1999 V6 camry. Is it OK to run it for 1 OCI (6k miles)?
thanks
 
#3 ·
nope, unless your in cold ass weather, the difference in weight wont do anything.
i'm trying to find out which oil i like best my self.
have used the Q HP 5w30 and its pretty sweet, but so is is the valaline.
i hear fully synth castrol is one of the best though... think thats what i'm using next ha ha
 
#12 ·
What about Mobil-1 0W-40? It's the only US Mobil-1 product that can be used in place of the 5W-30 specified by MB 229, BMW LL-01, and VW 502/505. (And no, US Mobil-1 5W-30 doesn't meet MB, BMW, VW/Audi specs as it doesn't have sufficient film strength).

Of course, if the prices are similar might as well get the 5W-30 fully synthetic from MB, BMW, or VW/Audi. But in my view dinos work just fine in Toyotas.
 
#18 ·
people claim they get more mpg with synt so they think they are saving money somehow on gas but the cost of syth vs dino dosent add up to the mpg you save. honestly its just a waste of money and in some cases its not that great for your engine. seeing on syth oil is lighter if you have an older car its easier for it to leak of burn off witch it did in my 98 camry. just get yourself some toyota oil filters and mobile 5w-30 and youre all set
 
#25 · (Edited)
people claim they get more mpg with synt so they think they are saving money somehow on gas but the cost of syth vs dino dosent add up to the mpg you save. honestly its just a waste of money and in some cases its not that great for your engine. seeing on syth oil is lighter if you have an older car its easier for it to leak of burn off witch it did in my 98 camry. just get yourself some toyota oil filters and mobile 5w-30 and youre all set
hmmm, is synthetic really more expensive ?

$15 for 5qts of dino (e.g. Castrol GTX +filter), max 3 mo / 3k miles
$29 for 5qts of synth (e.g. Mobil1 +filter), max 6 mo / 5k miles, some would say 10k is safe (never tried)
I believe that is per official oil change intervals unless I'm mistaken. proportions are clearly 1:2. synth is double price, double life time and at least double mileage.

somewhat depending on how we compare them, mileage-wise vs time-wise, but either way synth comes up at the same price or CHEAPER ... unless I am totally wrong, then sorry.

also I hear opinions from mechanics that synthetic is actually better at lower/cold temps making cold engine to start smoother.

However I agree with a statement that synthetic should be avoided for old cars that used to run on dino all the time, especially if driver was not religious about oil change intervals. reason is that dino as mentioned above can cause sludge buildup faster than synth, so there might be already some deposits actually sealing old cracked seals. then once you switch to synthetic oil, some of those thicker particles might get solved or dislodged (like when you use engine cleaning additives to crankcase) - all of that may result in oil leaks after switch to synth on an old car.

My '00 Solara used to run on dino for all its life until last July when i switched it to Penzoil Platinum synth. I was lucky I guess or my religious attitude about oil change intervals paid off, all is well now running Mobil1 Full Synthetic, car runs like a charm.
 
#28 ·
Hi,
This thread got revived again. I posted my question a while ago. Anyways thought I will share some info as I am already 2K miles into my OCI. The 5W20 Q HP for some reason sheared a lot after the first 1 K miles and I lost oil pressure (red oil light staying on for a couple of seconds after starting). I put in about 4-5 oz. of STP oil treatment to thicken the oil and my oil pressure is back up again.

All said and done, I will not use 5W20 in this motor any more after this OCI. The motor seems to shear oil very fast.
Thanks
 
#32 ·
Honestly almost all synthetic oils are the same. They all have the same additive package but different bases. Overall, their purpose is the same so you can mix half Q and half mobil 1 and the car will run fine.
c'mon think with your dipstick jimmy :thumbsup: