Toyota Forum banner

Why did you choose Camry over the rest?

12K views 85 replies 35 participants last post by  LandsharkJB  
#1 ·
I'm getting ready to buy my first Camry and first new car ever. I'm a 33y male w/ family and it seems like the best choice to make. I had no ambitions to be an Autocross driver and Atlanta traffic is so bad, so my car just needs to be sporty enough to navigate my way around the lady talking on the phone while putting on her make up and the guy reading the morning paper- yes I've seen both :headbang:

I would like some replies on why you decided to buy your Camry and anything you would do over in buying it, i.e. less, more options, color, model, even a different car. I'm planning on buying a 2013 Camry SE I4, White/blk int. no sunroof, because of the popping issue and hopefully get some michelin tires on it.


My Short list, just my opinion from research and test drives:

Camry SE: Affordable, reliable and quiet but doesn't have some of the pizazz and standard tech as some of the redesigns (push button start, turn sig. on mirrors, back up cam., power seat). But it does have a good stereo and comfortable seats and a refined engine. What sold me was it is one of the lowest price of almost all the midsized cars, nice minimalist style- kind of like the classic square iPod design in white, best reliability and cost to own. Win win :thumbsup:

Sonata SE: Modern-look with looks of gadgets (that can brake and are expensive to repair), poor steering, best warranty, great pricing, good acceleration but over all feels unrefined. Kind of like when I buy generic cereal because it's sitting next to the named brand cereal and it's cheaper, but when I get home I realized it tastes just a bit off, even though it has the same ingredients s on the box, something like that. Over all a good car with a boatload of extras. I so really want to like this car.

Mazda 6: This car was almost a winner. Love the style, features and handling. Best looking of the bunch and has a quality feel to the interior. All the modern stylings of a new car Mazda hit right on the head: Large grill, sporty look, decent rear lights, good use of chrome overall, curvy, pronounced body lines and great rims, looks much more expensive than it costs. But as much as I want to say I need a "drivers car" I really don't. I'm 6'3 and want a roomy, cushy interior. I understand it's interior is simple, elegant and focused providing the driver with ergonomic needs, not playing with space aged gadgets and ritzy designs. But I do a lot of road trips in the family and sitting in traffic so I want a car that has a fun and interesting interior. Plus it's a new company and car (since Mazda/Ford split) so there is bound to be some growing pains and issues that need to be worked out. Plus the car is in high demand and short supply= High price. Made in Japan good= Good quality, but expensive OOW repairs in the future.

These didn't make it on my short list

Optima- Wanted to like it like the Sonata. It's looks great inside and out, but the headrests pushed my head so far forward it was a deal killer. They were REALLY uncomfortable like who was this car made for. my saleswoman said that she hears that a lot and recommend turning them around after adjusting them back as far as they go. I can't enjoy a car while my neck is hurting.

Accord- CVT issues, shifting problems, engine sputtering look it will shut off while taking a curve, crappy stereo sound, voice cancelation issues, rattles and pops, hard ride. Maybe once they've worked out there 1st year issues, but not now.

Fusion- Not interested in another Ford after my well maintained Taurus experienced the "Black Death" issue, google search it. The stuck on baby aston martin grill on a plump, overstuffed car does nothing for me.

Altima- Is ok, but nothing stood out to me unless you got the higher, expensive trims and the CVT in my rental was bad until you put it in S mode which sucked down gas. Merging in traffic it took a second to think about moving. It's computer should be able to process things faster than my CPU (brain) can.

Maibu: Looks cool. But haven't bothered looking into it since I can't find one person that says it's worth buying over the rest.

Sorry for writing the novel. If all goes well I'll post pics of my new SE at the end of the month. Thanks for reading this far!:thanks:
 
#2 · (Edited)
there are plenty of threads and posts about it and I'm personally wasted a lot of letters explaining in details why I picked camry over competitors.
camry fits my expectations, needs and life style better than any other car in the family segment.
my second choice would be used ES350.
accord, optima, passat, fusion were too far behind these two.
 
#6 ·
This may sound superficial.... but I wanted to be the first to own one. I got it Oct 2011 and didn't see another one until next year. Plus I got a great deal on it (Thanks to Truecar) and it had the class leading MPG.

Passed on Accord because it was 5 years old with antiquated technology plus many complaints about its seat. Altima had the cheapest looking interior ever, looked like a $10k car and seat was too low.

But if I were buying today, I'd probably get the Accord or Altima over the Camry. Mazda 6 looks like a Buick with that fat bloated front end. Reminds me of a whale shark. Sonata has twice as many owner complaints as Camry and Accord. And I don't trust Hyundai when it comes to MPG since they've been caught lying so much.
 
#22 ·
That's cool to have the 1st model redesign out. As you drive by people are wondering what it is. I bought a used 2006 civic coupe in 2007 and people were still asking me what kind of car is that?

i was going to get an Altima had my mind set on that and no one could convince to look at another car.

the accord was a close 2nd because i have a 04 honda thats still running like a champ.

i wasnt even interested in the carmy to being with was on the 6th gen tho.


i test drove the Altima and loved everything it came with (2.5s)

but my pops always rocks with toyota had a 94 pick up, 03 corolla s and now has a 2008 sienna

he convinced me to go test drive the Camry

we went and once i drove that car i feel in love idk what it was but my desire for the Altima just wasnt the same anymore, even my pops told me he noticed my reaction when we were driving the car.

didnt buy it that day but i knew i would be getting this car soon.


fast forward 2 weeks. after going to different dealers to find a good deal, a week ago today i got my 2013 SE and love it
Congrats, smart Pops! I was into the Altima also until I rented it on a trip. Then I knew I had to cross it off my list.

Well the only way you can get the "Push button start" is in the V6 SE. The back up cam and power seats can be added if you don't see one at the dealer.
Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
I'm know you can get a push button start and power seat with options on the I4 SE, I just wish at least one of those came standard on the I4 SE. Power seat is pretty easy to find, but push button is only if you get an I4 loaded. If I can find a V6 cheap enough I'll get it... but 4 grand more plus higher gas price is a lot for me.

I haven't see any I4's. Just the V6 and there usually loaded ( Back up cam, sunroof, Entune, etc)


Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
exactly!
 
#7 ·
I own a 2013 Silver SE V6 loaded. I paid 32k. My freight company moves all of the North America Pre-production parts that Toyota uses to assembly and crash test future model years. I've always owned domestic cars and will definitely buy another Toyota. The Camry handles great, has plenty of power (V6), and gets good fuel mileage. Plenty of room inside the car (I'm 6 2) and the trunk has plenty of room as well. Great car. You can't go wrong in my opinion. Also, resale is good if you ever decide to get rid of it.


Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
 
#8 ·
i was going to get an Altima had my mind set on that and no one could convince to look at another car.

the accord was a close 2nd because i have a 04 honda thats still running like a champ.

i wasnt even interested in the carmy to being with was on the 6th gen tho.


i test drove the Altima and loved everything it came with (2.5s)

but my pops always rocks with toyota had a 94 pick up, 03 corolla s and now has a 2008 sienna

he convinced me to go test drive the Camry

we went and once i drove that car i feel in love idk what it was but my desire for the Altima just wasnt the same anymore, even my pops told me he noticed my reaction when we were driving the car.

didnt buy it that day but i knew i would be getting this car soon.


fast forward 2 weeks. after going to different dealers to find a good deal, a week ago today i got my 2013 SE and love it
 
#11 · (Edited)
#13 ·
Also found this.

Camry SE

The sporty Camry SE starts around $750 above the Camry LE. Included in that figure are several items to woo shoppers interested in a more exciting drive than the normal Camry provides. Those features include a rear spoiler and fog lights. The Camry SE also adds sport suspension for improved handling and steering-wheel paddle shifters for more control. Rounding out the upgrades are 17-in alloy wheels.
The Camry SE is also available with Toyota's powerful 268-hp 3.5-liter V6. Choosing that engine adds around $4,000 to the base price, though it also includes 18-in alloy wheels, Toyota's Entune infotainment system, a power driver's seat and keyless access with push-button starting.
Options for the Camry SE include leather and suede upholstery, a navigation system, heated seats, a lane departure warning system, a power sunroof and a blind-spot alert system. Many of the SE V6's standard features are also optional on the 4-cylinder model.


Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
 
#17 · (Edited)
We were between the Sonata SE and Camry SE. At the time, the new Fusion, Malibu, Mazda 6, or Accord weren't out yet. We didn't even bother looking at VW's and were blown away by how incredibly cheap the 2012 Fusion was (the 2013 is a HUGE improvement).

Camry won out because it drove a little better than the Sonata (road noise was much less on Michelins (and then ended up buying a Bridgestone model), super light steering on the Sonata, visibility on the Sonata was terrible) and there were TONS of rebates that made it almost too good not to buy.

If we'd waited, and she'd known stick shift like she does now, it would probably be an Accord sitting in the driveway. But that Mazda...that's a fine car.
 
#19 ·
I really wanted to get the new Accord since my first car was a 1995 Accord EX that had 220K miles before it got totaled. After reading stories in the forum about the CVT, cheap stereo sound, rattles and the direct injection engine, I decided to look for something else. My dad (he owns a 2001 Tundra and 2012 Sienna) told me to test drive the new Camry. I test drove one, fell in love and drove it home that day.
 
#20 · (Edited)
I'm getting ready to buy my first Camry and first new car ever. I'm a 33y male w/ family and it seems like the best choice to make. I had no ambitions to be an Autocross driver and Atlanta traffic is so bad, so my car just needs to be sporty enough to navigate my way around the lady talking on the phone while putting on her make up and the guy reading the morning paper- yes I've seen both :headbang:
Funny you mentioned this.

We have a 93 Camry that is still going strong today. I test drove the Sonata several times. The Sonata is better looking in my opinion than the Camry - kinda looks like an Audi. However, after spending *several* days reading many users posts on Sonata and Hyundai reliability issues, specially on Consumer Reports owners postings, I stopped considering the Sonata. The Sonata is also VERY noisy inside the cabin when driving - it would drive me nuts after a few weeks of that harsh noise.

The reason I picked the 2013 Camry Hybrid instead of a regular Camry is that the Hybrid is much better suited for conjested freeways.

My freeway commute is stop and go with 10-20 miles per hour movement most of the time. I am not sure how to describe it, but the Hybrid is a LOT more pleasant to dive in this type of environment. When I let go of the gas pedal, the electric motor begins to stop the car automatically ( places the energy back into the batterys ) so I find myself NOT having to reach for the break pedal as often.

With the old Camry, once I let go of the gas, it glides freely and so I find myself having to jump for the breaks a lot sooner in heavy traffic.

Moral of the story is that if your commute is anything like mine, heavy freeway traffic, the Camry Hybrid will be easier and more enjoyable to drive. Super quiet when running in EV mode in slow traffic. :D
 
#23 ·
After driving a dozen different car makes and models I choose the Camry SE I4. Handled better, stopped better, was quieter and rode better than anything else I drove.

The Kia Optima. Honestly I think this is the nicest looking 4 door on the road inside and out but the test drive was horrible. Popping, squeaks, rattles and just a cheap feel.

Accord - Great looking car with nice features. I would have bought one IF the Sport was more sporty and (this is the big one) it didn't have that CVT trans. What a POS that thing is. I got the trans "confused" according to the sales person by punching it to get on the expressway. Just a horrible driving experience.

None of the other compared to the Camry. IT also helped that I bought a 2012 in ealy 2013 so they were giving them away.
 
#24 ·
We chose the Camry because it was mainly what my wife had her mind set on(it would be her car). If it were up to me I would've seriously considerred other models.

But out of the cars you listed:

-I mentioned my thoughts about Mazdas in the other thread regarding if people regretted not getting the 2014 Mazda 6 instead. Used to be a big fan but am kind of skeptical about it's quality. It's kind of interesting to hear that they split from Ford, so maybe their quality will improve.

-I really like the styling of the Kia Optima and most of the Kias as well. I also like the styling of some of the Hyundais, where they look a bit more conservative then the Kias. I think the Korean automakers have a lot of potential and you get a lot for your money. But my opinion is still kind of skewed because I remember when they started to sell their vehicles in the late 80s and mid 90s, it was mostly junk that would sell for less than a grand a couple of years later. Than even when it looked like they were improving in the early 2000s, we knew a couple of people that bought Hyundais probably because of the great value and when asked about their opinion said that they loved it. But then shortly afterwards I noticed that they traded it in for another brand. So I think while they have potential they're not quite their yet. Of course once they're there, they'll probably be more expensive too.

-I'm wary of the CVT transmission and that automatically crossed a lot of vehicles off the list like the Altima and Accord. I know CVT is probably the future, where it sounds like the next gen Corolla will have it too. But hopefully by that time all of the issues with the CVT tranmissions will be figured out by then. This is actually probably the main reason why the Camry was on top of our list.

-I liked the looks of the previous generation of the Fusion. Not so crazy about this current, which is one of the reasons why we didn't look too closely at it. But my opinion of domestics are also still kind of based off of their quality in the 80s. I do see them doing a turnaround and improving but am still skeptical like with the Korean manufacturers. Also the list price for the Fords and other domestics, seemed to be a lot higher than similar models by other manufacturers.

One thing that I would do over in the purchase of our car is being more familiar with the extended warranties a little bit more beforehand. In the past I never really bothered with the extended warranties because thought that they were mostly a gimmick for the dealer to make more money. However I don't really believe in the quality of cars these days, the roof popping noise of the Camry being an example. So decided to get it for the peace of mind. I originally wasn't planning to and wasn't sure what price point to work with. Afterwards I found this link(which I probably found from this forum):

http://slickdeals.net/f/1258591-Toyota-Extended-Warranties-1-2-price?page=40

That lists the prices that are supposedly to be good deals for the warranties. We ended up doing okay based off of these prices listed but guess we probably could've gotten a better deal. I think the resources for shopping for a Toyota is great, because later on when I tried to find if there was similar info for Nissan couldn't find any similar information on their pricing for extended warranties.

If you're not getting a sunroof, you may be okay without the warranty.
 
#26 ·
>>The Kia Optima. Honestly I think this is the nicest looking 4 door on the road inside and out but the test drive was horrible. Popping, squeaks, rattles and just a cheap feel.

Really? Other than some cheapness to the feel in the basic model, I thought overall it was pretty responsive and good. Only question is reliability. Also, I don't like the dual exhaust for the 4 banger. It was a 2013 and there were no squeaks.
 
#27 ·
Models looked at prior to purchase; Camry, Optima, Sonata, Accord, Malibu, Mazda 6, Fusion, and Passat. Overall, I liked the ride/drive and looks of the Passat best. Malibu was very quiet, All the others except for the Camry, exhibited a kind of "klank" when the rear suspension went over speed bumps or other road imperfections. The Passat and the Camry, over the same roadway, exhibited a " whump", or rather a "muted" sound. Kinda like a Mercedes. You can feel the bump but the metallic noise is just muted out. Why the Camry, well it was second overall to the Passat but I could not get past the VW's reliability histories, mpg, and the Price. To equip the Passat, as close as possible to my SE, drove the "drive out price" to more than $3000 higher than Camry, which might be mitigated "if" the resale value at 4 or 5 years was higher then Camry. It is not. So based on overall "value" and "perceived ride and drive, The Camry SE won. (with Michelin tires that is, I refused two Camry's they brought out because I would NOT buy with the Bridgestone tires. Don't get me wrong, BS and Firestone make some excellent tires, but not the EL400's offered on the Cam. If you don't believe it, test drive an identical Cam with both sets of tires. Insist on a highway run not just a block or two around the dealership. You choose the road not the sales person. Oh yeah, before I forget, I really liked that the CamSE is "grounded to the ground" ! LOL
 
#28 ·
Lik'in our 2012 XLE I4

I have a fairly loaded XLE I4 with the push button start, not aware how they package the SE's. We (mainly my wife) wanted some options like dual temp control and headed full leather only available on XLEs. Personally I like the exterior look of the SEs but did drive one a few miles and the tight suspension was much rougher, more like the Accord, so my butt liked the XLE better too.
The Camry won over 2nd place Subaru Legacy a strong contender in snowy states but extra maintenance, packages*, and the crappy Bridgestone tires vs Michelins on our XLE made the final difference. 15 mons ago the LEs and SE Camrys only had Bridgestone tires vs XLEs had Michelins.
Good luck on your purchase!
* I really wanted a backup camera and it came part of a reasonably priced option package in the Camry vs Legacy was in a $2500 Nav package. It was not available on the 2012 Passat, interesting that car wasn't on your list.
 
#32 ·
Our Choice......

Our choice was the 13 Toyota Camry XLE V4 and we LUV It!

We were thinking originally the Avalon but it was to high end even thought it comes in Low, Prem and Touring.

One factor we also were consideing was our local unfortunately parking problem. 10 inches would make a difference.

We road tested it twice. First we tried a Camry LE can did not like it. We found blind spots we were concerned about.

I did once rent a Camry LE which did not impress me.

When we were making a decision about not considering the Avalon, we thought twice about getting the almost equal to the Avalon - Camry XLE. Close to the Avalon but high end interesting bells and whistles in the XLE.

One more road test but a SE was only availble. Did not like it. To rough a ride. Not sure due to possible 18" wheels. Read SE have been reported to be rough thru out the different forums and reviews.

We did want certain features that were on the brochure with XLE which included Display Audio and Navigation. Also impressive backup camera. We did want Blind Spot Assistances but that would have to come from the factory. A five to six week.

Our car was supplied to us thru the dealer tristate inventory search. Silver was hard since it came in black cloth interior.
We wanted leather package.

Took about 4 weeks with constant searching and had to give another color choice. We selected Superior White.

In three days, Super White came up with all we wanted.

Consideration also with space inside for my two senior citizen parents. To make it easy for their in and out of the car. This model worked.

Within 5 days it was transported to our dealer and preped for pickup the next day.

We love it and Super White is loved by all with our selection. The color seems to fit the look over all the others.

One of the other considerations with a light car and interior color was to reflect off the sunlight too keep the car and interior cooler instead of attracting the heat.

138 miles on now can looking forward to driving it each day.

We made the right choice...
 
#33 · (Edited)
We love it and Super White is loved by all with our selection. The color seems to fit the look over all the others.

One of the other considerations with a light car and interior color was to reflect off the sunlight too keep the car and interior cooler instead of attracting the heat.
Very true. We also love lighter exterior and interior colors: White, Silver, and Champagne are the best of course :D

Black is way too difficult to keep clean. Every little spot shows and here in SoCal in the summer time, black will burn your hand and if you touch it. I don't like all black interiors either - depressing.

Image
 
#36 ·
well i dont trust the CVT technology yet so that right their pushed a lot of cars out of consideration.i rented a 12 camry le to drive about 600 miles for business.i would have never considered this car before that.and i wanted to stay under 24,000 out the door.i dont care about leather seats and I didnt want a sun roof for any reason. just bluetooth and quiet decent ride with good gas mileage. so camry it was.
 
#40 ·
Longo prices are in-line with TrueCar - varies a bit. I did 95% of my searching / buying through email and the last 5% was phone calls to verify details, performing the transaction, etc.

I went to several Toyota dealership to try out the new cars and I also went to CarMax. CarMax is good because I was able to test drive different cars on the same day and I quickly narrowed in on what I liked and did not like.

I worked with Steven M. Hess, Longo Toyota Internet Sales. Overall a very pleasant experience and straight forward transaction :thumbsup: with no stupid games you find at just about every dealer out there.
 
#57 ·
i have a 2011sev6 fully loaded with the exception of push to start and keyless entry. When i was looking for a car it came down to the mazda6 with the v6 and the camry with the v6. Within 25-50 miles i believe there were only 3 camry's that fit most of my needs. There were no mazda6 that i could find. I am happy with the camry though with the exception of 15 miles to the gallon and the very noisy piston slap everyone has.I absolutely love the power it doesn't make my heart race or make me smile like how a mazda would but its mine.
 
#58 · (Edited)
I am happy with the camry though with the exception of 15 miles to the gallon .
For those looking for power and fuel savings which are usually mutually exclusive, try the Camry Hybrid.

Camry Hybrid has 205HP and uses two motors ( electric & gasoline ) when you press it goes while giving you 40+MPG.

I am still amazed how much power the TCH has when needed.